Contradiction resolution programme
All six contradictions have been reassessed against event-linked and boundary evidence. Narrowing a dispute is not the same as resolving it.
Narrowed: 3
Still disputed: 0
Resolved: 3
| Contradiction | Outcome | Evidence basis |
|---|---|---|
CTR-001 |
resolved | GAF-2026-001 |
CTR-002 |
narrowed | EVT-2026-002, EVT-2026-008, EVT-2026-009, EVT-2026-012 |
CTR-003 |
resolved | GAF-2026-004 |
CTR-004 |
narrowed | BND-002, EVT-2026-010, EVT-2026-011, EVT-2026-013, EVT-2026-014 |
CTR-005 |
resolved | GAF-2026-005 |
CTR-006 |
narrowed | GAF-2026-006, EVT-2026-015, EVT-2026-016 |
Assessment details
CTR-001 — resolved
Resolved by GitHub’s first-party five-minute Quickdraw criterion; issue equivalence and processing delay remain documented limitations outside the timing dispute.
CTR-002 — narrowed
A pending review request is now distinguished from a submitted review and did not prevent the linked award. Submitted COMMENT, REQUEST_CHANGES, APPROVE, dismissed-review, automation-review, and merger-identity cases remain open.
CTR-003 — resolved
Resolved by GitHub’s first-party x4 Pull Shark milestone history: 2, 16, 128, and 1024 merged pull requests.
CTR-004 — narrowed
Two independent GitHub-linked squash cases preserve attribution when the final commit retains the trailer. Rebase or fast-forward behavior, stripped trailers, email mismatch, later rewrites, and exact tier counts remain open.
CTR-005 — resolved
Resolved by GitHub’s first-party x4 Galaxy Brain milestone history: 2, 8, 16, and 32 accepted answers.
CTR-006 — narrowed
Current organization ownership does not necessarily erase creator attribution: two GitHub-owned fragments credit personal creators for organization-owned repositories. Transfer timing, forks, archival, falling counts, deletion, restoration, and award persistence remain open.